Preface: I am proposing a challenge based on this mystery. If you wish to know more about this challenge, please be sure to read the Challenge section found at the end of this blog post.
Congratulations to Grazyna Zreda and Alfredo Tifi who both solved Chemical Mystery #8. While neither Grazyna nor Alfredo figured out exactly how I pulled off this trick, they both determined that I was making use of the “salting out” phenomenon. In the “salting out” experiment, a water-soluble ionic salt is added to a mixture of water and a water-soluble organic liquid. If enough salt is added, the mixture separates into two layers: one rich in water, and the other rich in the organic liquid.1 You can see how this works (and also the solution to Mystery #8) in the video below:
In Mystery #8 I used acetone as the water soluble organic liquid and table salt as the ionic substance. I first mixed acetone, water, and two different dyes without adding any salt. The yellow dye was obtained from yellow food dye, while the blue dye was obtained from blue glitter. The dye on blue glitter dissolves very well in acetone, but not so well in water. The other yellow dye dissolves very well in water, but not so well in acetone.
Acetone and water dissolve well in one another due to hydrogen bonding interactions between the oxygen atom on acetone molecules and the O-H bond on water molecules (Figure 1).
Figure 1: Representation of a hydrogen bond (yellow dashed line) formed between a molecule of acetone (lower molecule) and a molecule of water (upper molecule). Image made using Odyssey modeling software.
All four of these components mixed very well together (acetone, water, blue dye, yellow dye) to form a green colored solution results. When a lot of table salt was added, the green solution separated into two layers: a blue colored, acetone rich layer on top and a yellow-colored, salt-water rich layer on bottom. How did this occur?
When the salt dissolved into the mixture, the resulting Na+ and Cl- ions interacted very strongly with water molecules through ion-dipole forces (Figure 2). These ion-dipole interactions attracted water molecules much more strongly than the acetone-water hydrogen bonds. As a result, the ion-dipole forces pulled water molecules away from acetone molecules and the liquids separated into the two separate phases. The yellow dye, which dissolves better in water than in acetone, ended up in the salt water layer. The blue dye, which dissolves better in acetone, ended up in the acetone layer.
Figure 2: Representation of a chloride ion (green) interacting with six water molecules through ion-dipole forces (yellow dashed line). Image made with Odyssey modeling software.
What is interesting about this project is that one can use many different combinations of dyes, organic liquids, and salts to achieve different effects. For example, Graznya Zreda “solved” this mystery by reporting that she mixed yellow food dye, water, blue food dye (in place of the blue dye found on glitter), isopropyl alcohol (in place of acetone), and potassium carbonate (in place of salt). Upon mixing these items a beautiful green solution was observed; adding potassium carbonate separated the mixture into the blue and green layers (Figure 3).
Figure 3: Experiment carried out by one of Grazyna Zreda's students. Left to right: Test tubes containing yellow food dye in water and blue food dye in 70% isopropyl alcohol; Mixing the yellow and blue fluids to form a green solution; Addition of potassium carbonate to form a green solution; separation into blue and yellow layers upon dissolution of potassium carbonate.
Grazyna and I began communicating on Twitter about these experiments, and one afternoon we even spent an hour or two “together”, electronically messaging back and forth about various experiments we were trying. This was really a lot of fun! Throughout our combined efforts, we discovered some really cool things. First, green food dye alone (in place of both blue and yellow) can be used in Grazyna’s version of this experiment! That’s because green food dye contains a combination of blue and yellow food dye. Second, using different blends of organic liquid and ionic salts with blue food dye and purple “fall color” food dye resulted in completely different results (Figure 4).
Figure 4: Color combinations achieved using blue food dye, purple “fall color” food dye in conjunction with (Left) acetone, salt, and water; (right) isopropyl alcohol, potassium carbonate, and water.
Challenge: Finally, here is a challenge I am proposing for you and your students based on this experiment: See if you can create layers that display your school colors by modifying this experiment using different combinations of ionic salts, dyes, miscible organic liquids and water. If you achieve this, see what other color arrangements you can create. I'm particularly interested in seeing a purple/green combination! I would love to hear from you regarding different combinations you are able to create. Of course I would also be interested in hearing about your various successful recipes if you are willing to share them! Be creative…dyes can come from a surprising number of different sources…like glitter, of all things!
Reference: Shakhashiri, Chemical Demonstrations Volume 3, p. 266 – 268.
For Laboratory Work: Please refer to the ACS Guidelines for Chemical Laboratory Safety in Secondary Schools (2016).
For Demonstrations: Please refer to the ACS Division of Chemical Education Safety Guidelines for Chemical Demonstrations.
Other Safety resources
RAMP: Recognize hazards; Assess the risks of hazards; Minimize the risks of hazards; Prepare for emergencies
All comments must abide by the ChemEd X Comment Policy, are subject to review, and may be edited. Please allow one business day for your comment to be posted, if it is accepted.
Love this activity
Made a couple of these and put them on my desk. Lots of non stop questions from students....awesome demonstration.
Glad you like it!
Thank you for letting me know you tried this out, Chad. Be sure to let me know if you or your students come up with some new color combinations.
Very nice demonstration.
Very nice demonstration. Thanks a LOT! I was looking different kind of demonstrations and especially some food color in the separatory funnel. Now I know to add purple color to water or salt water, put it on the separatory funnel and pour some acetone in the funnel... I hope that in Finland there is same kind purple color that you have. :)
I hadn't a suitable purple color at moment and I used Bromothymol Blue (BTB) with two drops of vinegar together with Brilliant blue (E133 in Europe) and BTB with a little sodium bicarbonate with yellow tartrazine (E102) or yellow 5. I haven't photos to decide which combination was better because the students tested the two alternative ways and kept photos in their smartphones, that means these are lost-unshared forever :-). In any case, BTB was extracted in the acetone phase both in the acidic and basic form.
I'm gonna have to try this...
Alfredo, this sounds very interesting. I'll be trying your experiment next time I'm in the lab. Thanks for sharing!
Hi, Juha, thank you for commenting. Be sure to add sodium chloride, potassium carbonate, or some other inorganic salt to the water. If you can't find the purple food color, just go ahead and experiment with whatever dyes you can find. In my experience, there are several different top layer/ bottom layer color combinations that are possible using various combinations of dye, inorganic salt, and organic solvent. Please let me know if you come up some interesting new color combination!
Curious if anyone knows what blue dye is used on the glitter? I would love to be able to have my students analyze the structures of both dyes to try to explain why one is more soluble in water and the other in acetone.
If you find out the answer to this, be sure to share it with us!
Slides to accompany
I used this to help my AP Chem students understand IMFs and polarity. I made some slides so that they could go along with this. In case anyone else would like the resource: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1cH3WhPrmy0_20GMcZuFiBJQA5VTrFIS8...
Thank you so much for creating this post and the instructions!! My students LOVED it.
Thank you so much for sharing your slides with us. It looks like you and your students have made some interesting color combinations as well. FANTASTIC!!
indigo is the blue dye?
thanks for your google slides. I didn't know that indigo (used in blue jeans) was the dye in blue glitter! I guess i never thought about it. Is this listed anywhere or how did you find out this. Just curious.
Very interesting! I'm going to save it to launch a challenge to my students!!
Polarity of dyes?
Thanks for a great video - I'm hoping to use this experiment with my students but hoping you can shed some light on a problem I'm having... Using green food dye I get a wonderful separation with the yellow dye in the bottom layer of more dense K2CO3 solution, and the blue dye in the upper layer of less dense isopropyl alcohol. This suggests that the yellow dye is more polar than the blue dye. HOWEVER, when I use that same green dye in paper chromatography, with water as the mobile phase, the blue dye travels further than the yellow, suggesting the blue dye is more polar than the yellow! Am I getting the layers the wrong way around - is the isopropyl alcohol in fact denser than the K2CO3 solution?
This is an extremely interesting question! Your results with the paper chromatography experiment potentially make some sense if we recall that paper generally contains a lot of cellulose, and is therefore quite polar. I suggest running the paper chromatography experiment again using acetone or isopropyl alcohol as the mobile phase. My guess is you will get the same result (blue dye traveling further than the yellow dye), but the yellow dye shouldn't travel as far as it does when water is the mobile phase.
Let me know how it works for you if you try using alcohol or acetone as the mobile phase!
Strange color change
Somewhat similar to Sasha's comment. I had one group that got the blue acetone on top and the other color on the bottom in the salt layer. Pretty soon, two groups came up to me with blue going to the bottom and the top solution was PINK! My brain stuck for a second and then was wondering what in the world happened. I can tell you that the bottom layer is salty and the top is acetone, but now my blue color went to the bottom. Here are some variables that have me wondering where to go next with this. The kids could choose whatever color they wanted in the water and I had some neon food coloring choices. I took out the blue and actually added a drop to the acetone because I was impatient for the blue to come off the glitter. It worked great with the other groups and seemed to be working fine. Then, I get this random pink coloring on top and blue on the bottom. I'm thinking that the neon dyes did this, but I want to know your thoughts on how to further this to figure out exactly what took place.
Check out Figure 4 in this blog post. Is this what you observed?